Multi-family Property Management in New Jersey

Expert Management for Large-Scale Apartment Owners

Sutton Property Management is a family-owned property & asset management company specializing in the operations, leasing, renovations and financing of multi-family apartment buildings across the Garden State and the greater New York metropolitan area.

We manage every aspect of apartment ownership — from rent collection and maintenance coordination to capital improvement projects and financial reporting — so owners can focus on portfolio growth.

We are an approved property manager by both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, authorized to manage Class A, B, and C multifamily assets throughout New Jersey. In addition to being approved managers, we’ve successfully sourced and closed loans with both agencies, providing our clients with an end-to-end understanding of the lending and operational landscape.

Why Owners Choose Sutton Property Management

1. Proven Track Record in Multi-family Operations

For over a decade, Sutton Equity (our parent company) has operated and repositioned multifamily properties throughout New Jersey. NOI growth across the portfolio has exceeded 75%, a direct result of disciplined operations and data-driven management.

2. Deep Local Experience

We understand every market — from university towns like South Orange and Montclair to coastal communities like Long Branch and Asbury Park. Our local vendor relationships and knowledge of township requirements ensure speed, compliance, and cost control.

3. Value-Add Mindset

We approach property management as asset management. Each property receives a customized improvement plan that includes rent optimization, renovation scheduling, and energy-efficiency upgrades to maximize NOI and long-term valuation.

4. Data-Driven Transparency

Owners receive clear monthly performance dashboards tracking occupancy, collections, and expenses. Our goal is predictable returns and actionable insights — not guesswork.

Our Core Services

Full-Service Property Management

• Rent collection, accounting, and owner reporting
• Preventive and emergency maintenance coordination
• Lease renewals, tenant screening, and compliance management

Renovation Oversight & Value-Add Execution

• Unit and common-area renovations
• Vendor bidding and supervision
• Cost tracking and quality control

Owner Representation

• Budget forecasting and capital planning
• Insurance and municipal compliance
• Asset repositioning strategies for refinance or sale

Who We Serve

We partner with:

• Private owners of 20–500 unit multi-family properties
• Family offices and investment groups seeking reliable day-to-day operations
• Developers and asset managers needing a New Jersey-based operational partner

Our experience ranges from stabilized Class A assets to full-turnaround Class C repositioning.

Our Service Area

We proudly serve:

• Essex County
• Union County
• Passaic County
• Monmouth County
• Bergen County
• Morris Counties

The Sutton Advantage

• Locally based, responsive management
• In-house renovation coordination
• Strong vendor network across trades
• Transparent owner reporting
• Proven track record in NOI growth

Contact Sutton Property Management

Ready to improve your property’s performance?
Contact our team to discuss how Sutton Property Management can enhance the value, stability, and tenant experience of your multi-family portfolio.